Uses and costs for security window film vs. bulletproof glass
March 6, 2019
Scissors are great for cutting things, but you wouldn’t use them to mow your lawn or trim your trees. It’s a similar story with security window film. It may provide protection against shattering and intruders, but it doesn’t solve every security challenge. Sure, security film has undergone many advances, but the fact remains: it doesn’t stop bullets.
Businesses, schools and other organizations – especially those eager to find low-cost ways to boost their security – need to understand some important product distinctions. When applied properly, security window film can boost your facility’s forced-entry and blast defenses. Meaningful protection against gunfire only comes from UL-rated bullet-resistant glass enclosures.
Safe Uses for Security Window Film
As you examine your threat profile, whether it involves potential robberies, vandalism or weather events, consider the following acceptable uses for window security film:
Smash and Grab Burglaries
Windows protected with security film can buy you precious time to call for help and even deter intruders during a break-in attempt. The film absorbs the energy of the blow, making it more difficult for a criminal to break glass doors or windows with a crowbar or hammer.
Are you located in an area where natural disasters, such as hurricanes, tornados or earthquakes, are common? Is your location prone to vandalism? Any of these events can cause fragile glass to shatter into dangerous shards and projectiles, posing serious safety concerns. Security film holds glass fragments in place to minimize damage and injury. Some films, when properly attached to the window frame, can achieve blast-resistance ratings because the film stretches and pulls against the frame, leaving the window fragments intact.
Businesses and residences have used window film to reduce the effects of the sun since the early 1960s. The film moderates interior exposure to harmful ultraviolet rays, protecting people and furnishings, and helping to regulate heating and cooling within a facility.
Installation Costs for Security Window Film
If you are looking at window security film as part of your strategy for hardening your building, you’ll want to choose the right level of film, and understand the costs. Similar to bulletproof glass, there are many factors that can impact the pricing of a security window film project. Some of those factors include:
- French pane charges
- Difficult working conditions
- Removal of existing film
- Moving of furnishings
- High ladder work/swing stage/scaffolding/lifts
- Travel and accommodations, etc.
We spoke once again to window film expert Brad Campbell, Founder and CEO of Campbell Window Film, to get a rough idea of what the materials might cost:
“We generally use the 3M Ultra 8 product which is 8 mil thick but stronger than standard 8mil due to 3M’s unique cross lamination of multiple micro-thin layers. It’s like rip-stop nylon compared to regular nylon. That said, Ultra S800 8mil Clear unattached will run $8 to $18 per square foot for materials and the labor to install it.“
Where Bulletproof Glass Makes Sense
If your security concerns go beyond moderate break-in and shatter protection, and you’re worried about armed robberies or active shooter situations, UL-rated bullet-resistant glass offers the ballistic protection that other materials simply can’t provide.
UL assigns the material a specific rating from Level 1 to 8, indicating how many of what caliber bullets it can stop, based on certified lab testing. While Levels 4 to 8 are typically reserved for government and military facilities, Levels 1 to 3 satisfy the needs of most customers. Bullet-resistant enclosures commonly protect financial institutions, schools, convenience stores, law enforcement offices and healthcare facilities.
Watch the following video to see a gunfire demonstration with a 9mm handgun to better understand the level of protection that each solution provides to a building and the lives inside.
Typical Bulletproof Barrier Costs
Although costs for bullet-resistant glass run higher than security film, it’s an apples-to-oranges comparison. The two products meet different security needs, although bullet-resistant glass often serves multiple purposes, holding certified ratings for forced entry, explosive blasts and hurricane winds.
Costs depend on square footage, as well as additional features and accessories you may need, such as doors, currency trays or package passers. Level 1 to 3 glass can run from $45 to $85 per square foot dependent on material (this is material cost only and does not include ballistic framing or installation).
A basic barrier system – something suitable for a stand-alone ticket window or after-hours transaction window – typically costs $3,000 to $5,000, not including installation costs. A more complex barrier system for a gas station/convenience store or small bank branch runs about $15,000 to $20,000. Again, this will depend on what material you chose, how many stations are needed, and does not include installation costs.
Bottom line, you’ll have true ballistic protection in place that security films can’t deliver.
@TSSBulletProof #TSSBulletProof #security #bulletresistantglass #bulletproof #securitywindowfilm
Company: Total Security Solutions Inc
Product: Ballistic Security Glass
The all-hazards approach to ballistic barriers and physical security (December 7, 2018), What industries should utilize bullet-resistant glass? (August 28, 2018), 2018 Trend: Custom Corporate Security Systems (August 20, 2018), Securing your bulletproof glass investment in 2018 (December 18, 2017), Bullet Proof Barriers For Utility And Electric Co-Op Offices (November 21, 2017), Attractive Bulletproof Barrier Design (October 27, 2017)
Why Choose Glass Deck Railing? (November 26, 2018), Non-destructive testing: when safety & success must be absolutely assured (November 9, 2018), Energy saving glazing options cut energy costs (October 31, 2018), What industries should utilize bullet-resistant glass? (August 28, 2018), 2018 Trend: Custom Corporate Security Systems (August 20, 2018), Design Spotlight: Controlling Summer Sun (August 3, 2018), 7 Fun ideas using glass to jazz up your outdoor patio or deck this summer (July 27, 2018), Thermal performance and energy savings with polycarbonate glazing systems (July 16, 2018), Design spotlight: enhancing the grid (June 3, 2018), Elevare™ Mullion High Wall System (May 16, 2018)
9 Reasons Organizations Select Security Revolving Doors to Protect their Most Valuable Assets (March 1, 2019), 3 Reasons Mantrap Portals Provide the Highest Level of Security Compliance for an Entry (January 14, 2019), How security entrances can help protect data centers by controlling physical access (December 14, 2018), The all-hazards approach to ballistic barriers and physical security (December 7, 2018), Four Elements of Security Entrance Safety that Directly Impact Your ROI (November 7, 2018), Energy saving glazing options cut energy costs (October 31, 2018), What industries should utilize bullet-resistant glass? (August 28, 2018), Wood door solutions for high-risk areas (August 24, 2018), 2018 Trend: Custom Corporate Security Systems (August 20, 2018), Aesthetics: When Looks and Beauty Matter for Security Entrances (August 15, 2018)